Hi! I'm a hardcore lurker on your page but I'm delurking to see if you had heard Summer Begs by Sarah Jaffe. I haven't made it all the way through your last.fm tracks to see if you had, but the bit towards the end of the song when the strings kick in always sounds like heartache to me and would fit nicely with a story.
If not, I would just say Pornography by Katy Rose rpf: KStew/Dakota.
...also would you be willing to upload any Amanda Rogers you have? I only have a few tracks and I haven't been able to find full albums